The Fact About hp-38 powder That No One Is Suggesting
The Fact About hp-38 powder That No One Is Suggesting
Blog Article
Assessments can only be submitted while being logged in. You should enter your login facts down below. New client?
I used to be basing my alternatives on forum posts I had read on this and One more reloading Discussion board. In the intervening time I really Never recall which 1 touted 231 a lot more hugely, but it absolutely was very advisable.
Did you recognize something about this load facts? All these hundreds use a similar precise demand weight! So I can actually improve above cartridges rather than even really have to mess Together with the powder measure!
The question remains, when did these powders change, and whenever they altered whole lot to great deal, can it be really wise to simply call HP and 231 the identical powder?
By subscribing you agree to our privateness policy and will be the first to find out about promotions, Particular delivers and products releases.
Cleaner than Titegroup and Much better in general performance. Not as cost-effective although, since you have to have a bit far more powder in the case, and the cost of HP38 is slightly much more. This is a superb faster burning powder, fantastic.
Michael, It really is excellent that you'll be noticing signs of stress and asking why. That suitable there boosts your chance in producing Protected handloads IMHO. In almost any circumstance not long ago posted data will likely be a lot more conservative and that is a superb matter.
Insert to quote Only clearly show this user #60 · Sep thirteen, 2015 robertbank, I agree with all your put up ... except the component about pistols operating with lighter loads of W-231 / HP 38 or maybe lighter loads with other powders. I've been In this particular business for a very long time and have take a look at fired a huge selection of pistols. It's common for a box stock pistol in almost any caliber to are unsuccessful to function with lighter hundreds hp-38 powder ... in reality some 9mms Do not even operate well with lighter 115gr bullets in normal manufacturing facility masses. I have a couple of myself .... a Browning Hi Electric power and a Walther P-38.
Having that info to all reloaders has been a problem. The SAAMI, Hodgdon, major reloading provide sellers, and Reloader Journal were many of the dependable motor vehicles for these notices. Also why powder suppliers and bullet makers put out new manuals each and every year or so.
Posted September 11, 2009 You dont see alot of data for HP 38 for the reason that the majority of people get it and seek advice from it by its other name, W231. exact knowledge same powder. HP38 powde You will discover tons of info when you lookup W231. And you simply are proper it truly is slower than Bullseye.
When it's genuine that they are usually made use of for the same application (they are doing have close to exactly the same burn up amount), they are not what I (or most people) would imagine as equal, they usually unquestionably are usually not interchangeable at the exact same powder weights.
I'd personally move to Common or Distinctive with a nod to Universal only because it flows far better plus much more consistantly than Special away from most powder actions.
Just what the rather terribly labeled ADI chart you cited truly is, is "around the same burn up amount" data. It's not at all a "these powders are a similar" chart. For instance, 700X and WST are claimed to get "equal powders" on that chart from ADI.
The excellent characteristic of HP-38, in my encounters, would be the exceptionally broad spectrum of different handgun cartridges, effectively above 25 by my count, and that there's an abundance of loading knowledge readily available from reliable resources, together with Wolfe Publishing’s have LoadData.com.